With over 300 hotels in The Bahamas, deciding where to stay for your perfect island getaway can be challenging. Whether you’re looking for luxury, adventure, or something more secluded, the best hotels in The Bahamas offer a variety of experiences, from world-class resorts to boutique hideaways.
However, if you’re dreaming of extending your stay and making The Bahamas a regular retreat, plenty of stunning oceanfront homes are also for sale. With its extensive local knowledge and years of experience, MCR Bahamas can help you find the perfect property.
But if you’re looking to start with a vacation, keep reading for our curated list of the best hotels in The Bahamas.
Table of Contents
Where are the Best Hotels in The Bahamas?
When it comes to the best hotels in The Bahamas, you’re spoiled for choice across its many islands, each offering something unique.
Nassau, the capital, is home to some of the most luxurious resorts, like the iconic Atlantis Paradise Island Bahamas resort. This option is ideal for those seeking a vibrant nightlife, shopping, and a bit of history.
If you’re after a quieter escape, Exuma is just one of many breathtaking options. Picture private islands and boutique resorts with thatched-roof villas surrounded by turquoise waters. These islands are known for seclusion, nature, island hopping, and the famous swimming pigs.
And then there’s Harbour Island, with its charming boutique hotels nestled along the famous pink sand beaches. This island is ideal for travelers seeking a relaxed, picturesque vibe with eco-friendly stays.
Alternatives to the Best Hotels in The Bahamas
If you’re looking for a more private, home-like experience in The Bahamas, consider the following options.
Luxury Condos
For those who want modern amenities and convenience, luxury condos are the way to go. There are plenty of options for those interested in renting a condo, with average rental prices ranging from $2,000 to $5,000 monthly.
If you’re thinking of staying here permanently, MCR Bahamas has a fantastic selection of luxury condos for sale.
Oceanfront House Rentals
Imagine waking up to the sound of ocean waves every morning—that’s what you can expect with an oceanfront house rental. These homes offer incredible views, direct beach access, and unparalleled privacy.
And if you just so happen to fall in love with The Bahamas during your stay, why not make it permanent? Buying an oceanfront property with a luxury real estate firm like MCR Bahamas allows you to find the perfect property for your preference and budget.
Villas
You can’t go wrong with one of MCR Bahamas’ villas to take luxury to a new level. These properties are often tucked away on the quieter islands, offering a private and exclusive retreat.
Villas come equipped with everything you could need during your stay, including private pools, fully-equipped kitchens, and sometimes even personal chefs and staff. These accommodations are ideal for families, groups of friends, or couples seeking that ultra-exclusive feel.
Private Island Rentals
Only around 30 of the over 700 islands in The Bahamas are inhabited, leaving plenty of untouched beauty to discover. Renting a private island gives you total seclusion, with just you and your guests there to enjoy the pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and personalized service.
If you’re looking to go all out, MCR Bahamas can provide you with the ultimate luxury experience with its curated selection of private island rentals.
Best Hotels in The Bahamas
Here are the best hotels we recommend for short-term stays in The Bahamas.
1. Rosewood Baha Mar
Location: Nassau, New Providence
Best for: Luxury seekers and families
Located on Nassau’s Cable Beach, Rosewood Baha Mar is the epitome of refined luxury. With spacious, beautifully appointed rooms, private beach access, and personalized service, it’s ideal for those looking for elegance. Guests enjoy top-tier dining with five distinct culinary experiences, a lavish spa, and access to Baha Mar’s casino and Jack Nicklaus-designed golf course.
For those who can’t get enough of the area’s charm and sophistication, MCR Bahamas offers luxury condos and oceanfront properties for sale in and around Baha Mar.
2. The Ocean Club, A Four Seasons Resort
Location: Paradise Island
Best for: Couples and luxury travelers
Since its opening in 1962, this iconic resort, set on a 5-mile stretch of white-sand beach on Paradise Island, has been known for its upscale charm and stunning location. The Ocean Club offers Michelin-star dining and iconic Versailles-inspired gardens and abbey. It also offers luxurious rooms and villas, either beachfront or more secluded ones for privacy. It’s perfect for those seeking romance and exclusivity.
3. Kamalame Cay
Location: Andros Island
Best for: Privacy and a romantic getaway
Kamalame Cay is a secluded private island resort on a 96-acre cay, offering intimate beachfront villas, cottages, and bungalows. With private beaches, spa treatments, and a barefoot luxury vibe, it’s the perfect retreat for honeymooners and couples who want an off-the-grid experience.
4. SLS Baha Mar
Location: Nassau, New Providence
Best for: Trendsetters and nightlife enthusiasts
Opened in 2017, SLS Baha Mar combines chic, modern design with an electric social atmosphere. The hotel features stylish rooms and suites, including the ocean-facing Signature Suites. Trendsetters will enjoy dining at renowned restaurants like Cleo Mediterráneo and Katsuya, as well as the lively scene at Skybar, a rooftop lounge.
The resort also boasts the adults-only Privilege pool with luxury cabanas, making it a hotspot for those who love socializing, nightlife, and contemporary luxury.
5. Caerula Mar Club
Location: South Andros Island
Best for: Eco-conscious travelers and nature lovers
Caerula Mar Club offers a truly secluded, eco-luxury experience. The resort’s beachfront bungalows and private villas are sustainably built with natural materials, blending luxury and environmental responsibility.
Guests can enjoy the pristine, untouched surroundings of South Andros Island and indulge in a tasty dining experience at Lusca, Driffs Beachbar, or Switcha. You can also unwind at the resort’s zero-footprint spa. This resort is perfect for an eco-friendly, off-the-grid escape with first-class service.
For those captivated by the tranquility and natural beauty of South Andros, MCR Bahamas provides exclusive listings of eco-friendly homes and private villas. You can quickly turn your island escape into a permanent retreat surrounded by nature.
6. Sandals Emerald Bay
Location: Great Exuma
Best for: All-inclusive luxury and golfers
Opened in 2010, Sandals Emerald Bay is a premier all-inclusive resort offering world-class amenities. The property is home to an 18-hole, Greg Norman-designed championship golf course, and its white-sand beaches are among the best in the Bahamas.
Couples will appreciate the Butler Elite service, the Red Lane Spa, and fine dining options like La Parisienne.
However, we want to note that Sandals Emerald Bay is currently transitioning into a Beaches Resort, aimed at providing a more diverse and family-friendly vacation experience with a broader range of activities for guests of all ages. The reopening date is yet to be announced.
7. Grand Isle Resort & Residences
Location: Great Exuma
Best for: Families and group travelers
Grand Isle Resort, established in 2004, offers expansive villas ranging from one to four bedrooms, all equipped with full kitchens and stunning ocean views.
Perfect for families and groups, the resort provides a more private, home-away-from-home feel with access to Emerald Bay Beach, a beachfront infinity pool, and the SeaStar Spa. Guests can also enjoy dining at The Palapa Grill, 23° North, or Sandy Toes.
8. Grand Hyatt Baha Mar
Location: Nassau, New Providence
Best for: Travelers seeking an all-encompassing resort
Opened in 2017, Grand Hyatt Baha Mar delivers a vibrant mix of luxury, entertainment, and relaxation. Guests can access Baha Mar’s casino—the largest in the Caribbean—the 18-hole Jack Nicklaus Signature golf course, multiple pools, and more than 40 restaurants and bars, including Marcus at Baha Mar Fish + Chop House. It’s ideal for travelers looking for a comprehensive island experience without having to leave the property.
9. The Cove
Location: Paradise Island
Best for: Adults seeking a private escape
Part of the Atlantis Resort, The Cove has been offering a more exclusive experience for discerning travelers since 2007. With spacious, ocean-facing suites, private balconies, and a focus on luxury, this adult-only property is perfect for couples or those seeking tranquility.
Guests can unwind at the secluded Cove Pool, a private adults-only oasis with private cabanas and an outdoor gaming pavilion, or enjoy world-class dining at Freedom Restaurant and Sushi Bar.
10. French Leave Resort
Location: Eleuthera
Best for: Couples and off-the-beaten-path travelers
Nestled in the picturesque Governor’s Harbour, French Leave Resort offers elegant villas with panoramic ocean views, each equipped with a private pool and expansive verandas. This intimate resort provides an ideal escape for couples seeking relaxation and adventure.
Explore the pink-sand beaches, or enjoy fine dining at 1648 An Island Restaurant, known for its locally sourced seafood.
11. Graycliff Hotel
Location: Nassau, New Providence
Best for: History buffs and foodies
Built in 1740 by Captain John Howard Graysmith, Graycliff Hotel is a historic mansion that exudes old-world charm and luxury. The hotel is home to one of the Caribbean’s finest restaurants, the five-star Graycliff Restaurant, and its award-winning wine cellar, cigar company, and chocolate factory.
History enthusiasts can enjoy exploring the mansion’s past, while food lovers can revel in gourmet meals and curated culinary experiences. It’s perfect for those seeking a unique blend of history, luxury, and gastronomy.
For those drawn to Graycliff’s timeless elegance, MCR Bahamas offers stunning homes and estates nearby. These allow you to embrace the same blend of history, luxury, and charm in your own residence.
More About the Best Hotels in The Bahamas
If you still have more questions about the best hotels in The Bahamas, we have the answers to help you choose the perfect stay.
What is the best part of The Bahamas to stay in?
This is a difficult question to answer, considering the uniqueness of every island in The Bahamas. To choose the best part of The Bahamas to stay in, you must know exactly what you want.
If you want a bustling city vibe with plenty of shopping and dining options, Nassau is an excellent choice. If you want a quieter retreat, consider Harbour Island or the Exumas.
Other great places to stay include Eleuthera, The Abaco Islands, Bimini, Paradise Island, and Grand Bahama.
MCR Bahamas can help you explore real estate options across these diverse locations, whether you’re looking for a permanent home or a seasonal getaway.
What is the prettiest place in The Bahamas?
Beauty is subjective, but the prettiest place in The Bahamas might be the Exuma Cays. With its crystal-clear waters, powdery white sand, and the famous swimming pigs of Big Major Cay, it’s a tropical paradise that captures the essence of island beauty.
Harbour Island’s Pink Sand Beach, about 3 miles long, is also a top contender, providing a unique and picturesque setting that’s hard to beat.
What is the safest island in The Bahamas?
The Bahamas has many safe islands to live on, including New Providence, Eleuthera, and the Abaco Islands.
The Bahamas is known for being a safe and welcoming destination, making it an attractive place to consider living permanently. With MCR Bahamas’ expertise, you can find stunning homes and properties anywhere in The Bahamas, ensuring you can enjoy paradise with peace of mind.
What is the most luxurious hotel in The Bahamas?
According to Forbes, The Ocean Club is the most high-end hotel in the Bahamas. With Michelin-starred dining by Jean-Georges Vongerichten and elegant accommodations ranging from ocean-view rooms to private villas, guests are treated to unparalleled luxury.
Its iconic Versailles Pool and 12th-century cloister add a unique touch of European charm, making it a truly exceptional escape.
Where do celebrities vacation in The Bahamas?
Celebrities often flock to the Exuma Cays and Nassau. The secluded islands of the Exumas offer privacy and exclusivity, making them a favorite among the rich and famous. Nassau also attracts celebrities with its high-end resorts and vibrant nightlife.
However, several celebrities like Oprah Winfrey, Johnny Depp, Faith Hill, Michael Jordan, Tyler Perry, Nicholas Cage, and Eddie Murphy own private islands in The Bahamas.
Explore the Best Hotels in The Bahamas
From the bustling luxury of Nassau to the serene shores of South Andros Island, the best hotels in The Bahamas offer something for every type of traveler. Whether you’re looking to indulge in world-class amenities, relax on pristine beaches, or immerse yourself in the natural beauty of the islands, you’re sure to find your perfect escape here.
But if you’re thinking about staying a little longer—or perhaps even calling The Bahamas your second home—MCR Bahamas is here to help. Not only can we assist in finding top-notch vacation rentals, but we also offer a range of stunning homes for sale, perfect for anyone wanting a more permanent piece of paradise.
Contact MCR Bahamas today to explore our listings!