The Best Real Estate Agents in Exuma, Bahamas

exuma bahamas
Mario Carey

Bahamian real estate agents are the ultimate professionals when it comes to buying or selling your home on an island paradise. With average listing prices of $2 million and a booming economy, many families and individuals are looking to take part in this exciting market, specifically in the Exuma district of The Bahamas.  

But where do you start when it comes to choosing a real estate agent in The Exumas?

There’s no doubt that Exuma real estate agents have intimate knowledge of the Bahamian market and can provide you with resources and information that will guarantee you the best experience possible. In this guide, you’ll find all you need to know about buying a home in The Exumas–and the best real estate agents to help you. 

Ready to buy your luxury home in the Bahamas?” Contact us at MCR Bahamas, we can help!

About Exuma, Bahamas  

The Exumas are a long stretching expanse of 365 cays that form part of the Bahamian archipelago. With that many cays, you have enough places to explore for every day of the year! Exuma is also renowned for having stunning turquoise waters, warm and soft beaches, as well as lush vegetation. 

Exuma is split into 3 different parts: The Great Exuma, Little Exuma and the Exuma Cays. The Great Exuma and Little Exuma are known for being popular tourist destinations and the Exuma Cays are known for having both luxury private homes and private islands.

Georgetown is the main settlement area of Exuma. It is home to a variety of shops and amenities. The Exuma International Airport (GGT) is only a 30-minute drive away from Georgetown and is a regular destination for tourists from Atlanta, Toronto, and Nassau.


Benefits of Real Estate in Exuma, Bahamas 


There are many reasons people buy a home in The Exumas. Many visitors to the cays fall in love with the elegant natural beauty and relaxed way of life of the islands. Others, however, are called by the lure of the active lifestyle and no shortage of fun awaiting them. 

Everything from sailing, golfing, fishing, and watersports are popular pastimes in Exuma. So it’s no surprise many come as tourists and end up becoming island inhabitants. 

Here are a few reasons why people choose to move to The Exumas:

  • It’s foreign-investment friendly.
  • The stable economy and government 
  • Homes with excellent rental potential 
  • Direct flights from Atlanta, Florida, and Toronto, as well as connecting flights at Nassau.
  • Low taxes and no income tax
  • Exuma offers a warm climate all year round.
  • Property values in Exuma are prospering.
  • There’s no shortage of variety when it comes to Exuma properties.
  • You can become a permanent resident when you own a property valued $500,000 or more


Best Real Estate Agents in the Exuma & Exuma Cays & The Bahamas

Buying a home in The Bahamas is a huge decision. When you’re ready to make the leap, finding a real estate agent who can guide you through the process seamlessly is key. And there’s no shortage of real estate agents vying for people’s attention via online ads and newspaper listings. 

That’s why we’ve compiled a list of the best real estate agents in The Exumas, as well as provided options for real estate agents throughout all areas of The Bahamas. 


Best Real Estate Agent for The Exumas: Dean Spychalla 

best real estate agent in the exumas

About: Dean Spychalla, General Manager of Grand Isles Resort on Exuma, is an industry veteran with more than 30 years of experience in the hospitality sector, and is a leading Exuma Real Estate Agent at Better Home and Gardens MCR Bahamas

After graduating with a degree in Business Administration from the University of Wisconsin, Dean went on to work for numerous high-profile brands including Norwegian Cruise Line, Driftwood Hospitality, and Prism Hospitality Management. 

He’s won several awards, including The Bahamas Hotelier of the Year for 2017, and is currently the President of The Bahamas Out Islands Promotion Board as well as the Senior Vice President of The Bahamas Hotel and Tourism Association.

Dean is the premier real estate agent for the Exumas and Exuma Cays–the are in The Bahamas that he calls his home. 

Additional Best for these Bahamas Locations: Emerald Bay 


Phone: 242-357-0318



Timothy Smith 

best real estate agent in exumas bahamas

About: Timothy Smith has built a respectful reputation as one of the most exceptional real estate agents in the Bahamas. Born into a real estate family in Nassau, Tim is a Business Administration graduate from Georgia State University. 

His strong work ethic and extroverted personality led him back home to work at one of The Bahama’s top accounting firms. Later, he jumped into real estate and quickly became a top performer at Better Homes and Gardens MCR Bahamas Group

He’s well-versed in helping international and local buyers purchase all properties, from commercial investments to residential condominiums. He earned the prestigious title of Overall Top Producer of the Year at the firm two years in a row. And in 2021, he was appointed Partner.

When he’s not helping clients pick top properties and drafting stellar offers, Tim likes to play watersports and loves diving. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Gun Point North Eleuthera, Ocean Club Estates, Port New Providence, Cable Beach, Paradise Island, Chippingham, Columbus Cove, Saffron Hill, Bahamar


Phone: 242-426-7292



Tim Rodland 

real estate agent in the exumas

About: By the age of 36, Tim Rodland was named partner at Better Homes and Gardens MCR Bahamas–after only seven years with the firm. But it isn’t that surprising when after only four years on the team he earned platinum status with Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate. This made him one of the youngest in history to achieve a top 3% in sales globally.

Tim found a knack for sales at a young age. This drove him to study entrepreneurship and business at New York Clarkson University. By 2012, he would join Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate. 

He’s represented owners of private islands and resorts as well as luxury residences in exclusive communities including but not limited to: Lyford Cay, Old Fort Bay, Ocean Club Estates, and Port New Providence.

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Governors Harbour, Cable Beach, Love Beach, Paradise Island, West Bay Street, Coral Harbour, Yamacraw, Winton, Lyford Cay, Nassau New Providence, Blake Road, Delaporte Point, Ocean Club Estates, Fox Hill, Sandyport, Serenity, Skyline


Phone: 242-357-7475



Mario Carey

best real estate agent in the bahamas

About: Mario Carey is the President and CEO of Mario Carey Realty (MCR). He is well-known as one of The Bahamas’ most respected real estate professionals and and has attained the designations of Broker/Appraiser, former Vice President of Bahamas Real Estate Association (BREA), Certified International Property Specialist (CIPS), Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) and Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS).

 Mario not only holds the record of selling the largest beachfront property of $21 million in the Bahamas, but he’s also been the Top Producer of real estate transactions in Ocean Club Estates since 1999.  With over 30 years of sales experience, Carey founded MCR Bahamas in 2008, and now employs a team of highly skilled associates who speak multiple languages and have an incredible passion for their clients, company, and the islands. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Nassau, Westridge, Downtown, Paradise Island, Albany Resort, Eleuthera, Ocean Club Estates, Sandyport, Serenity, Bacardi Road, East Bay Street, Russell Island, George Town, New Nassau and Paradise Island, Cable Beach, Paradise Island, West Bay Street, Coral Harbour, Palmdale, Westridge, Carmichael Road, Nassau New Providence.


Phone: 242-357-7013



Elizabeth Weech 

best real estate agent bahamas

About: Elizabeth Weech of Better Home and Gardens MCR Bahamas is a licensed real estate agent and property manager with eight years of experience. 

She moved to The Bahamas in 1994 and has been privy to the nuances involved with relocating and buying property in The Bahamas. She also understands that communication and responsible guidance are paramount to a successful business transaction.

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Paradise Island, West Bay Street, Cable Beach, Eastern Road, Nassau New Providence, Bayview Drive, Other North Eleuthera, Coral Harbour 


Phone: 242-557-9567



Antoine Adderley 

best real estate agent exuma

About: Antoine Adderley started his career with one of the leading insurance companies here in The Bahamas, and when the door opened for him to join the real estate field, he quickly took advantage of his knowledge of the Exuma market. 

Antoine has been in the real estate business as a broker and an appraiser, having joined Mario Carey Realty in 2012, and always makes mention that it is his dream job. Continually educating himself about the business, he prides himself on putting customer needs first and has been led by his motto: “service with integrity.” 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Gregory Town, Other New Nassau and Paradise Island, Cable Beach, Coral Harbour, Westridge, Carmichael Road, Village Road, Winton, Nassau New Providence, Oakes Field, East Street South, Fox Hill, West Winds, Camperdown, East Street, Prince Charles, Indigo, Columbus Cove, Mt Vernon, South Westridge, Lyford Cay, Nassau New Providence, Downtown Bay Street, Mt Vernon


Phone: 242-465-8951



Livingston Brown 

real estate agent in exumas

About: Livingston Brown’s resiliency, positive attitude, and high level of work ethic make him one of the best real estate agents in Exuma, Bahamas. With over ten years experience in the hospitality field–along with his CIPM Accreditation (Certified International Project Manager), CPRM Accreditation (Certified Project Risk Manager) and AHIT (American Home Inspector Training)–he brings a high level of expertise in his approach to real estate sales. 

Livingstons’ level of commitment to his clients will assure that they are serviced to the highest degree of professionalism, as well as provide a realistic outlook on the current state of today’s real estate market.

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Nassau, Nassau New Providence 


Phone: 242-427-2523



Eli Bullard 

real estate agents in the exumas

About: As a licensed Salesman and Appraiser, Eli Bullard’s relaxed and jovial personality enables him to collaborate with colleagues and take care of clients with a smile as he shows them the beauty of The Exumas.

Eli continues to educate himself and has gained a number of designations over the span of his career. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Staniard Creek, Cable Beach, Nassau, Nassau New Providence, Berry Islands


Phone: 242-809-6531



Samia Donaldson 

exumas bahamas real estate agents

About: Born and raised in Freeport, Grand Bahama, Samia Donaldson’s personal connection with The Bahamas is evident in all of her work. Graduating early from high school with honors,  completing an Associates degree in Accounting and then a Bachelor’s degree in Marketing, Samia’s educational achievements landed her positions at Bahamas Telecommunications Company, the Bahamas Festival Commission, and other distinguished organizations before she began her real estate journey. 

Samia’s marketing experience and skills, coupled with her business knowledge has enabled her to secure over $4M in listings to date–and she doesn’t plan on slowing down any time soon. Her drive for success and her positive outlook propels her to exceed sales targets in the Exumas, as well as client expectations. 

Samia’s passion for education and pursuing knowledge shines through her determination to surpass her peers in real estate, and is sure to bring the perfect purchase or sale for her clients. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Mangrove Cay, South Bimini, North Bimini, Other New Nassau and Paradise Island, Cable Beach, Old Fort Bay, Coral Harbour, Westridge, Sea Breeze, Nassau New Providence, Atlantis, Harold Road, Nautica, Nassau, Soldier Road, Balmoral, Venetian West, Sea Beach Estates, Old Fort Bay, West Bay Street, 


Phone: 242-677-8255



Daniel Lowe 

bahamas real estate agents

About: Daniel Lowe takes pride in being resourceful and diligent in obtaining results for his clients, being able to market to both local and international clients. With an understanding of the rental market in Nassau, Danny spearheaded the housing aspect for the relocation of 30+ families for a major trading company.  

He was also the recipient of “Rookie of The Year” in 2016, being the top producer for his bracket at Better Homes & Gardens MCR Bahamas Group, was the top producer in the rentals category in 2018, and was also featured on HGTV’s “Bahamas Life.” 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Other New Nassau and Paradise Islands, Cable Beach, Paradise Island, West Bay Street, East Bay Street, Lyford Cay, Nassau New Providence, Bacardi Road, Caves Heights, The Grove, Ocean Club Estates, Balmoral, Joe Farrington Road, Venetian West, Serenity, One Ocean, Western Road, Cable Beach, Eastern Road, West Bay Street, Downtown, The Balmoral.


Phone: 242-424-3499



Sheldon Pitt 

exumas real estate agents

About: Looking for your dream properties in Bimini? Licensed agent Sheldon Pitt was born and raised in the smallest, mystical island of the Bahamas and uses that experience and knowledge to make exceptional sales in Bimini and beyond. His real estate experience begins in Toronto, flipping houses and financing various commercial properties, and today he works with the incredible team at Better Home & Gardens MCR Bahamas. 

Sheldon’s small-island upbringing gives him an extra edge in helping families find the perfect, kid-friendly home on the island. And when he’s not making sales, you can find him camping, hiking, and enjoying the outdoors. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Mangrove Cay, Bimini Bay, South Bimini, North Bimini, Bimini, Eleuthera, Cable Beach, Love Beach, Old Fort Bay, West Bay Street. Adelaide, Coral Harbour, Westridge, Sea Breeze, Nassau New Providence, Bay Street, Love Estates, Nassau, Balmoral, Venetian West, Nautica


Phone: 242-544-7509



Olivia Armaly 

exumas bahamas real estate agents

About: Olivia Armaly is an American/Bahamian who has lived in a wide range of places–Nassau, Long Island, Abaco & Central Florida–throughout her life. These experiences give her a deep understanding of the importance of finding your perfect home wherever you are. 

With a background in criminal justice and hospitality, Olivia is both personable and passionate about the work she does as a real estate agent in The Bahamas. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Bacardi Road


Phone: 242-455-0062



Unni Marie Berg 

best exumas bahamas real estate agents

About: Unni Marie Berg is Norwegian, but she has called The Bahamas home for 14 years finding joy in helping people find their dream home. 

With her extensive entrepreneurial business background and her Bachelor’s in psychology from the University of Oslo, she has shown to be more than capable as a real estate agent. She realized her dream and her passion, and now her goal is to help others achieve their dreams. 

Plus, with her photographic eye and sense of attractive presentation, Unni loves to assist homeowners with staging and preparation before their homes go on the market. And what does she do in her spare time? Travels to the more remote islands and beaches in The Bahamas for more adventure and beauty.

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Guana Cay, West Bay Street, Columbus Landings.


Phone: 242-577-7511


Andrew Seymour 

top exumas bahamas real estate agents

About: Andrew J. Seymour is a young enthusiastic professional that spent his early college life honing his culinary skills at the hotel and tourism training center at the College of the Bahamas. There, he learned the creative and inventive skills which have served him well throughout his real estate career. 

Andrew has always had an interest in real estate in The Exumas, from acquisition to marketing and more. In 2013, Andrew became one of the first ever part-time real estate agents in the Bahamas–as well as the first part-time agent to close a transaction. He then made a television debut by starring in an episode of HGTV Caribbean Life in 2019 demonstrating his real estate agent success. 

Best for these Bahamas Locations: Nassau New Providence, Boatswain Hill, Golden Gates, Caves Point, Highland Park, Monastery Park, Pyfroms Addition, Nassau, Serenity, Columbus Cove, Prince Charles Drive, Nassau


Phone: 242-376-9789


Conclusion: Choosing the Best Real Estate Agent for The Exuma, Bahamas   

In today’s hyper-competitive housing market, it’s important you have the right realtor who understands your wants and gives you the expertise you need to land your dream home. 

With the team at Better Home & Gardens MCR Bahamas, you know you’re getting experienced realtors with proven track records. They know and love The Bahamas and can’t wait to share it with you. If you need help finding your ideal home in The Exumas, contact Dean Spychalla today.

Or, if you’re looking for real estate support to buy a luxury home in the Bahamas, contact us at MCR Bahamas today!

The Best Real Estate Agents in Exuma, Bahamas

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to top