- 47+ Best Bahamas Excursions & Tours [2025] - March 22, 2025
- The Best Place to Live in The Bahamas: Safest & Nicest Places to Live [2024] - March 21, 2025
- Places to Stay in Eleuthera, Bahamas: Everything You Need to Know [2025] - February 7, 2025
Key Takeaways:
- Eleuthera offers a range of accommodations, including luxurious villas, high-end resorts, and budget-friendly stays.
- Eleuthera is the ideal destination for beachgoers and nature enthusiasts, and flaunts breathtaking cliffs.
- MCR Bahamas provides expert assistance in finding the perfect rental, home, or property in Eleuthera.
Every island in The Bahamas offers its own unique blend of natural beauty, cultural activities, and local delights. In Eleuthera, that blend includes awe-inspiring cliffs, pink and white sand beaches, turquoise waters, friendly locals, and tons of opportunities for fishing and snorkeling.
While small, this island holds a bounty of adventures and unique experiences just waiting to be discovered. All you need is a guide to the best places to stay in Eleuthera, then your adventure can begin!
Interested in buying or renting property in The Bahamas? MCR Bahamas is here to help. With over 40 years of experience in the Bahamas luxury real estate market, we can help you find the perfect property with expert guidance and local insights. Get in touch today so you never have to say goodbye to these dazzling islands.
In this article, we’ll provide a starting point for places to stay in Eleuthera, from villa rentals to luxury apartments. Then, we’ll cover important tips and common questions to consider when finding a place to stay in Eleuthera.
Table of Contents
Why Stay in Eleuthera, Bahamas?
Eleuthera is the perfect hidden gem for nature lovers and aquatic adventurers. Known for its pink sand beaches on the eastern side and calm, clear waters on the Caribbean side, Eleuthera has the ideal setting for any activity.
Whether you want to explore blue holes and snorkel to see local wildlife or you’d prefer to observe the waves from the beach or a kayak, this beautiful island will fulfill your every desire.
For a cultural excursion, visitors can head to charming island towns like Governor’s Harbour to better understand everyday life in The Bahamas, all while admiring the colonial architecture lining every street. Indulge in fresh seafood at every stop and shop at local markets to bring home a beautiful memory.
With a stay in Eleuthera, you’ll avoid large crowds and tap into the tranquility of nature, all while enjoying luxury accommodations, authentic culture, and friendly service. Plus, a stay in Eleuthera means a front-row seat to unique attractions like Glass Window Bridge.
If you find yourself hesitant to say goodbye to Eleuthera, you’re not alone. The team at MCR Bahamas will help you find properties for sale in Eleuthera to fit your exact needs and taste.
Best Places to Stay in Eleuthera
Your ideal lodging choice comes down to your priorities, group size, and itinerary. Whether you prefer a private villa or a cozy budget bungalow, there are plenty of places to stay in Eleuthera to fit your needs.
Villa Rentals
If you’re traveling with a large group, looking for more privacy, or hosting a bachelorette or wedding in The Bahamas, a villa rental is a great option!
Villa rentals combine the comfort and high-end amenities of a resort with the space and exclusivity of a private home. While they typically cost more than the average rental, there’s a broad selection of options—from charming beachfront cottages to opulent estates with infinity pools and on-site staff.
Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat tucked away in nature or a fully serviced luxury experience with a private chef, daily housekeeping, and oceanfront views, there’s a villa in Eleuthera to match your vision. Families with kids will appreciate the extra space, full kitchens, and home-like feel, while honeymooners can enjoy secluded, romantic getaways in breathtaking settings.
With over $2 million in local property sales under our belt, the team at MCR Bahamas is equipped to help you find your dream villa rental in Eleuthera.
Get in touch today to discover the perfect private retreat on one of The Bahamas’ most stunning islands.
High-End Resorts
For a seamless, all-inclusive experience, stay at one of Eleuthera’s high-end resorts, where luxury meets island charm. These resorts offer top-tier service and premium amenities, allowing you to fully unwind while surrounded by paradise.
Relax by pristine pools, stroll along private beaches, and savor world-class dining with fresh, locally inspired cuisine.
Some high-end resorts in Eleuthera include:
- The Cove: A secluded paradise with stunning oceanfront villas and exceptional dining.
- French Leave: A boutique resort offering elegant accommodations with easy access to Governor’s Harbour.
- Pineapple Fields: A luxurious yet relaxed stay with a private beach club and spacious condo-style lodgings.
Luxury Apartments
Want a high-end experience without committing to an all-inclusive resort? A luxury apartment or condo rental is a fantastic alternative for travelers who prefer a mix of independence and upscale comfort.
With options ranging from sleek penthouses to stylish boutique condos, luxury apartment rentals give you the best of both worlds—elegance, convenience, and the freedom to create your perfect island experience.
Budget-Friendly Options
Planning to spend most of your time exploring rather than lounging in your accommodations? Whether you’re cliff jumping, scuba diving, or soaking up the sun on Eleuthera’s stunning beaches, you’ll need a comfortable and affordable place to stay.
Budget-friendly lodgings in Eleuthera include charming guesthouses, cozy beach bungalows, and small inns that provide the essentials without sacrificing charm.
Affordable stays don’t mean compromising on location—many budget-friendly lodgings are conveniently situated near beautiful beaches and key attractions, making them a great choice for travelers who want to make the most of their Eleuthera adventure.
Tips for Finding a Place to Stay In Eleuthera
With such a wide range of options, finding the ideal place to stay in Eleuthera for your needs can feel overwhelming! Start with these tips.
- Determine Your Budget: One of the largest factors for narrowing down accommodations options is your budget. Consider the length of your stay and the total amount you’ve set aside for your trip to determine your budget for lodging.
- Consider Location and Proximity to Attractions: Which attractions drew you to Eleuthera in the first place? Was it the pink sand beaches, the blue holes, or maybe the Glass Window Bridge? Look into the location of your top attractions and keep proximity front of mind as you research places to stay.
- Choose Your Desired Experience: What are you looking to experience in Eleuthera? Maybe unparalleled luxury, peace and quiet, or simple comfort among nature? No matter your must-haves, there are beautiful options to meet your needs.
- Book Early During Peak Seasons: During the holidays and outside of the rainy season, accommodations in Eleuthera can book out fast! Begin your search early so you can have your pick.
- Check Out Reviews: There’s nothing more informative than a firsthand account. In addition to browsing websites for each resort or hotel, read through reviews. Do the top-mentioned features align with your priorities? Do any concerning patterns arise throughout the reviews?
- Work With Local Experts: Researching places to stay can be difficult and frustrating. For the most reliable and stress-free experience, work directly with local experts. At MCR, we’re ready to help you find your ideal place to stay in Eleuthera using our deep familiarity with the local market and several decades of expertise.
Contact MCR Bahamas today to find the ideal spot for your Eleuthera getaway.
More on the Best Places to Stay In Eleuthera
Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about finding places to stay in Eleuthera.
What side of Eleuthera has the best beaches?
While the eastern side of Eleuthera is bordered by the Atlantic ocean, the western side neighbors the Caribbean and Great Bahama Bank. The beaches on each side have their own pros and cons: while the waters on the Caribbean side are calmer for swimming and snorkeling, the eastern side boasts incredible pink sand beaches.
Do you need a car in Eleuthera?
Yes, we recommend renting a car in Eleuthera in order to easily take full advantage of the island’s attractions.
Having a car gives you the freedom to explore Eleuthera at your own pace, from hidden beaches to scenic spots like the Glass Window Bridge. If you’re staying in one area and don’t plan on venturing far, you might manage without a car, but for the best experience, renting one is the way to go.
What celebrities are in Eleuthera?
Celebrities who own property in Eleuthera include Faith Hill, Lenny Kravitz, and Eddie Murphy. Likely drawn to the privacy and natural beauty of the island, these celebrities find a laid-back escape on the island. Want to follow their lead? Browse Eleuthera real estate for sale.
Explore the Best Places to Stay in Eleuthera
Travelers with dreams of snorkeling in clear waters, lounging in fine sand, or getting the adrenaline pumping on a cliff dive will all find reasons to fall in love with Eleuthera.
The wide range of lodging options and endless outdoor activities make it a dream destination for those craving some fresh air. With an authentic feel and a friendly community, Eleuthera is poised to become your new favorite destination.
If you’re ready to make Eleuthera your permanent home or invest in Eleuthera property, work with MCR Bahamas to find Bahamas land for sale or an existing property that meets all your needs. With a deep understanding of the specific nuances of each area, our team is poised to find you the perfect property.
Reach out to MCR Bahamas and find the perfect place to stay in Eleuthera.