Old Fort Bay Club: 2024 Luxury Review

old fort bay club
Mario Carey

Restored by British businessman Joe Lewis in 2002, Old Fort Bay Club is a prestigious gated community located on New Providence Island in The Bahamas. Exuding luxury and historical elegance, many A-listers have their eyes set on this place. 

As the Founder of MCR Bahamas, I’ve had the privilege of guiding countless individuals and families to their dream homes in this exquisite community. We are a full-service brokerage firm that has more than 40 years of experience in luxury real estate

Holding the record for the largest beachfront lot sale amounting to $21 million, I’m proud to be a testament to MCR Bahamas’s deep-seated knowledge of the market and passion for the community. We take pride in finding that perfect match between buyers and their ideal properties. 

In this Old Fort Bay Review, our goal is to provide you with a comprehensive overview, highlighting the exceptional lifestyle, world-class amenities, and luxurious homes that make this community so sought after. 

From the perspective of someone who not only works but also deeply values the essence of Old Fort Bay, I invite you to explore what makes this club not just a place to live but a place to thrive.


What Is the Old Fort Bay Club?

Opening in 2002, the Old Fort Bay Club is a private members’ club situated in New Providence Island, Bahamas. It epitomizes a sanctuary where history meets luxury. 

Initially built by the British in the 1700s amidst the tumultuous era of pirates and privateers, this fortress was a beacon of control in the Caribbean. Today, after a thorough and respectful renovation, Old Fort Bay Club emerges as a premier destination. 

Offering accommodations that blend comfort with a touch of historical elegance, it has captivated members with beautiful beaches, an exceptional dining experience, and the warm welcome of friendly staff. 


Everything To Know About Old Fort Bay Club

Old Fort Bay Club

Old Fort Bay in New Providence offers a unique blend of comfort, luxury, and history. Aside from being a very safe place to live in The Bahamas, it’s one of the most sought-after destinations for travelers and business visitors alike, any time of the year, from the vibrant months of September to the festive season in December.

Where in The Bahamas is the Old Fort Bay Club located? 

Old Fort Bay Club is a waterfront gated community in The Bahamas, particularly located in Nassau in New Providence Island. It’s situated east of Lyford Cay. 

Aside from being a tropical getaway, Old Fort Bay is also situated near the best private international schools in The Bahamas, including Lyford Cay International School. 

Dining at the Old Fort Bay Club

Old Fort Bay Club dining

Like other luxury communities in The Bahamas, the dining experience in Old Fort Bay Club doesn’t disappoint. It’s a mixture of casual and elegant. That’s why it won’t be a good Old Fort Bay review if we don’t cover it. 

The menu carefully curated by Chef Shaker Estephane showcases international cuisine prepared using only the best ingredients coupled with friendly and attentive service. 

Seaview Terrace

The Sea-View Terrace is located within the historic Clubhouse of the Old Fort Bay Club. As the community’s main restaurant, the Sea-View Terrace offers guests an exquisite menu that blends traditional Caribbean flavors with contemporary culinary techniques. 

Available from Wednesday to Sunday, it invites diners to indulge in a gastronomic journey while basking in the breathtaking views of the surrounding azure waters. The terrace, with its comfortable seating and ambiance of relaxed elegance, provides the perfect backdrop for both intimate dinners and leisurely lunches, making every meal a memorable part of the Old Fort Bay experience.

The Sand Bar

The Sand Bar offers a casual, seaside dining experience. This charming dining spot welcomes guests daily from 11 am until 6 pm, offering a relaxed atmosphere where the gentle sounds of the sea enhance every meal. 

Perfect for those seeking to enjoy the simple pleasures of island life, the Sand Bar serves up various dishes that capture the vibrant flavors of the Caribbean, all while you dine with your toes in the sand. 

Amenities and Accommodation of the Old Fort Bay Club

Old Fort Bay Club Accomodation

Old Fort Bay Club offers a deluxe suite, meticulously adorned with the finest antique furniture to give guests the feeling of stepping into colonial-era elegance. The suite features a king-sized bed with daily breakfast prepared by the club’s in-house chef and access to all amenities. You can inquire about the availability of their suites here

Here are some amenities you can enjoy at the Old Fort Bay Club: 

  • Beach: The beach is open daily for members to soak up the sun on loungers while having a cocktail. Members can also use non-motorized water sports equipment, such as kayaks, giant floats, and paddle boards. 
  • Fitness: The Old Fort Bay Club’s fitness center is where members can relax their minds and engage their muscles. Enjoy amenities such as weight equipment, cardio machines, and group fitness classes like yoga. 
  • Spa: The private spa offers natural restoration with deep tissue massage, Old Fort signature massage, and hot stone therapy. 

Old Fort Bay Club Outdoor Activities

Old Fort Bay Club Outdoor Activities

Old Fort Bay in The Bahamas is not just a haven of luxury and relaxation but also a vibrant hub of outdoor activities. It offers something for everyone who seeks adventure and fun under the sun. 

Here’s a glimpse into the exhilarating outdoor activities available:

  • Paddle Boarding: Glide over the crystal-clear waters of Old Fort Bay with paddle boarding. Embark on an activity that combines tranquility and exercise. The calm waters surrounding Old Fort Bay provide the perfect setting for exploring the coastline at your own pace.
  • Labyrinth: The Labyrinth is a unique outdoor experience designed to offer both a meditative walk and a playful adventure. This intricate pathway invites members to lose themselves in the beauty of nature as they navigate through its winding course.
  • The Great Lawn: This area serves as the heart of outdoor activities and gatherings at Old Fort Bay. This expansive, manicured space is ideal for a variety of recreational pursuits, from picnics under the Bahamian sky to family games and community events. 
  • Beach Volleyball: Set against a backdrop of sandy beaches and the blue sea, the volleyball court is a lively spot where guests of all ages can jump into a game, serving and spiking their way to a fun-filled day.

Beaches Near Old Fort Bay Club

Old Fort Bay Club beach

Near the luxurious enclave of Old Fort Bay in The Bahamas, several stunning beaches offer members a chance to immerse themselves in the serene beauty of the Caribbean.

  • Old Fort Bay Beach: This picturesque stretch of sand provides a private, tranquil beach experience. Situated within the Old Fort Bay community, this beach is an ideal spot for sunbathing, swimming, and simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Its proximity to the historic Old Fort adds a unique backdrop. 
  • Captain’s Beach: This beach offers a more secluded retreat, known for its pristine conditions and vibrant marine life. It’s a haven for snorkelers and divers seeking to explore the underwater world. 
  • Love Beach: A mile-long beach located in the northwestern part of The Bahamas, Love Beach is a bit further from Old Fort Bay. You can visit this beach for free. It’s less crowded than other beaches in the area, so you can enjoy a serene beach experience.


Old Fort Bay Real Estate

Whether you’re dreaming of a beachfront villa with breathtaking ocean views or a custom-built home nestled on lush, landscaped lots, Old Fort Bay presents an unparalleled real estate opportunity in The Bahamas. 

Navigating the prestigious real estate market of Old Fort Bay requires the expertise of seasoned professionals, and MCR Bahamas is the perfect real estate broker to guide you through this journey. 

With an extensive portfolio of properties and an intimate understanding of the Old Fort Bay community and real estate prices in The Bahamas, MCR Bahamas can be a valuable partner in finding your dream home. From exploring available listings and discussing average rental and purchase prices to securing your perfect piece of paradise, MCR Bahamas is committed to turning your vision of luxury island living into reality.


 Old Fort Bay Home

Luxury living in the enclave of Old Fort Bay in The Bahamas combines the allure of island paradise with unmatched elegance and sophistication. These residences range from sprawling beachfront villas with direct access to white sandy beaches and azure waters, to exquisite custom-built luxury rental homes that capture the essence of refined island living. 

Discover your dream home and let us lead you home.

Explore the exclusive listings available in Old Fort Bay at MCR Bahamas.

Estate Lots

estate lot

If you’re looking to invest in real estate in Old Fort Bay or build a home yourself, estate lots are a good option. These generously sized lots provide the perfect canvas for luxury living, where the vision of your ideal home can come to life. 

These estate lots are just a leisurely walk away from pristine beaches. Imagine the luxury of having the soft, white sands and crystal-clear waters of The Bahamas as your backyard, where the serene beach lifestyle is not just a vacation experience, but an everyday reality.

Take the first step towards creating your Bahamian dream home! Explore the available estate lots in Old Fort Bay with MCR Bahamas. 


More information about the Old Fort Bay Club 

In this Old Fort Bay review, let’s discuss additional information about this luxurious community. 

What is the history of Old Fort Bay?

Old Fort Bay’s history dates back to the 1700s when it was built by the British as a fort against pirates and privateers in the Caribbean. Over the centuries, it transformed from a military outpost to a luxurious residential community, blending its rich historical heritage with modern elegance and luxury.

Can you host events at the Old Fort Bay Club? 

Yes, you most certainly can! The historic Old Fort Bay Club is the perfect setting for any special occasion, including weddings. The community’s highly skilled culinary team and events coordinator together to help you create a memorable celebration. 

If you’re hosting a big event, the Great Lawn can accommodate up to 650 guests. Meanwhile, the Treetop Terrace, accommodating up to 120 guests, is the perfect venue for more intimate gatherings. 

What are the Old Fort Bay Club membership costs? 

There are three types of memberships offered by this exclusive community: general, junior, and corporate. 

To maintain its exclusivity and luxurious ambiance, membership is pricey. It involves an initiation fee of $75,000 and an annual fee of $5,000. This will provide you with full access to the club. 

Who Owns the Old Fort Bay Club?

In 2002, the restoration and development of the Old Fort Bay Club were initiated by British businessman Joe Lewis, alongside the Tavistock Group and the New Providence Development Company (NPDCo), culminating in its opening the following year.

In 2022, ownership of the Old Fort Bay Club and Old Fort Bay marina was granted to the Old Fort Bay Company Limited after an eight-year battle in court

Can you golf at the Old Fort Bay Club? 

There are numerous sports activities you can participate in at the Old Fort Bay Club, such as paddleboarding, basketball, beach volleyball, and more. However, this exclusive community doesn’t feature a golf course. 


Buy Your Bahamas Dream Home in Old Fort Bay

As we’ve explored the amenities, lifestyle, and exquisite homes within this prestigious community, it’s clear why so many, including US citizens, choose to call it home. 

At MCR Bahamas, our unparalleled experience and dedication have solidified our reputation as the leading real estate broker in The Bahamas. Our deep-rooted connection to Old Fort Bay and commitment to our clients’ dreams have allowed us to successfully match countless individuals with their ideal properties. 

Whether you’re seeking a serene waterfront retreat or an elegant estate, MCR Bahamas is your trusted partner in navigating the prestigious real estate landscape of Old Fort Bay. 

Let us guide you to your dream home in this paradise, where luxury and legacy meet!

Old Fort Bay Club: 2024 Luxury Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to top